2011 - Miss Fonda Fair Misty-Lynn Hilts, Junior Miss Kelsey Gray, Princess Alexandria Schermerhorn, Junior Princess Lillian Grace Lighthall.

2010 - Miss Fonda Fair Jessica Lape, Junior Miss Ashley McDuffee, Princess Alexys Conti, Junior Princess Tiffany Sargalis.

2009 - Miss Fonda Fair Lauren Crandall, Junior Miss Cory Lais, Princess Kaylee Cappuccio, Junior Princess Aireanna Muhlberger.

2008 - Miss Fonda Fair Courtney Sheridan, Junior Miss Katherine Bant, Princess Kimberly Sargalis, Junior Princess Haley Salisbury.

2007 - Miss Fonda Fair Amanda Morse Meredith, Junior Miss Alexis Sweet, Princess Frankilyn Greco, Junior Princess Alexys Conti.

2006 - Miss Fonda Fair Amanda Boyer, Junior Miss Merrissa Hart, Princess Kelsey Gray, Junior Princess Adrianna Snell.

2005 - Miss Fonda Fair Kieren Sheridan, Junior Miss Jessica Lape, Princess Ashley McDuffie, Junior Princess Kimberly Sargalis.

2004 - Miss Fonda Fair Vanessa Henry, Junior Miss Alicia Palmeri, Princess Courtney Truax, Junior Princess Monica DiScioscia.

2003 - Miss Fonda Fair Kristen Draus, Junior Miss Morgan Mooney, Princess Jessica Lape, Junior Princess Kelsey Gray.

2002 - Miss Fonda Fair Keelie Sheridan, Junior Miss Corey Pritchett, Princess Shenal Salluzzo, Junior Princess Cory Lais.

2001 - Miss Fonda Fair Heather Frees, Junior Miss Lynn Tryon, Princess Alicia Case, Junior Princess Erica Schermerhorn.

2000 - Miss Fonda Fair Rebecca Skretkowicz, Junior Miss Theresa Tokarowski Princess Victoria Tambasco, Junior Princess Ashley McDuffie.

1999 - Miss Fonda Fair Tiffany Gibbs Gritzuk, Junior Miss Elizabeth Gibbs, Princess Alicia Palmeri, Junior Princess Jessica Lape.

1998 - Miss Fonda Fair – Cindy Berry Hane, Junior Miss Jessica Obie, Princess Courtney Egelston, Junior Princess Jenna Wilder

1997 - Miss Fonda Fair Alicia Monette, Junior Miss Tammy Dingman, Princess Kimberly Dutcher, Junior Princess Morgan Tryon.

1996 - Miss Fonda Fair Samantha Clark, Junior Miss Jamie Walrath, Princess Amy Dimezza, Junior Princess Natasha George.

1995 - Miss Fonda Fair Rosalynne Overrocker, Junior Miss Jennifer Obie, Princess Jennifer Wolf, Junior Princess Cassandra Clark.

1994 - Miss Fonda Fair Jennifer Druziak, Junior Miss Samantha Clark, Princess Jessica Zugzda, Junior Princess Jackie Zugzda.

1993 - Miss Fonda Fair Heather Buanna Dukes Esq., Princess Kolbe Hill, Junior Princess Amy Dimezza.

1992 - Miss Fonda Fair Tracy Rose Cranker, Junior Miss Cindy Fiorenza, Princess Amanda Wilmot, Junior Princess Megan Streun.

1991 - Miss Fonda Fair Julie Sorber, Junior Miss Carrie Shinemann, Princess Amanda Seelow, 1st Birthday Girl Jessica Lampkin.

1990 - Miss Fonda Fair Katherine Rose, Junior Miss Heather Buanno Dukes Esq., Princess Jessica Reed.

1989 - Miss Fonda Fair Stacey Stevens Lemma, Junior Miss Heather Garrison, Princess Stacey Bryant.

1988 - Miss Fonda Fair Courtney Ramirez, Junior Miss Deborah Ramirez Mannino, Princess Georgette Ramirez Marinez.

1987 - Miss Fonda Fair Michele Mancini Nare, Junior Miss Jaclyn Connell Sculco, Princess Heather Buanno Dukes Esq.

1986 - Miss Fonda Fair Ann Marie Mormile, Junior Miss Patrica Lapier, Princess Alyssa Brown

1985 - Miss Fonda Fair Tricia Kearns Parlsow